Fostering Adoption

The adoption of sustainable soil management practices remains low across Europe (e.g., Heller et al., 2024). While some barriers are biophysical, many are socio-economic, including limited access to knowledge and technical advice, economic constraints, insufficient incentives, ineffective policies, and deeply rooted farming traditions and perceptions (Vanino et al., 2023; Thorsøe et al., 2023). The EJP SOIL program worked to bridge the gap between science and policy to encourage broader adoption of these practices. Efforts included evaluating available tools, exploring methods for stakeholder engagement, and developing strategies to create incentives.

Support tools evaluation

To make decisions about soil management that are conducive to soil health, land managers and other stakeholders need reliable information and appropriate tools. Decision Support Tools (DSTs) may serve multiple functions e.g., practical decision making, registration, and monitoring. Substantial differences exist in current fertilisation guidelines across Europe, in the content, in soil test methods and how crop nutrient requirements are calculated, in the format and in their delivery (Higgins et al. 2023).

Deliverables and reports

Dara Guccione, G., Pirelli, T., Phillips, A., & Varia, F. (2021). Resources, Infrastructure and Capabilities Inventory (RICI) online platform for policy stakeholders. EJP SOIL Work Package 8 Deliverable.

Higgins, S., Kadziuliene, Z., & Paz, A. (2021). Stocktake study and recommendations for harmonizing methodologies for fertilization guidelines. EJP SOIL Work Package 2 Deliverable.

 

Tools for stakeholder engagement

Stakeholder engagement is crucial, in various instances and arena, to foster use of existing soil knowledge, development of new soil knowledge and implementation of sustainable management of agricultural soils. Stakeholder consultations (e.g., Vanino et al. 2023, Thorsøe et al. 2023, Heller et al. 2024) allows to identi. Citizen science indeed raises awareness among participating stakeholders and contributes to develop soil knowledge (Mason et al. 2024). There is a need, however, to institutionalise soil health science-policy-practice interfaces, such as done in the EJP SOIL National Hubs
(Visser et al. 2023).

Peer reviewed articles

Mason, E; Gascuel-Odoux, C; Aldrian, U; Sun, H; Miloczki, J; Götzinger, S; Burton, VJ; Rienks, F; Di Lonardo, S; Sandén, T. 2024. Participatory soil citizen science: An unexploited resource for European soil research. European Journal of Soil Science e13470, (1-17).

Policy briefs and notes

Visser, S., Chenu, C., Besse, A., Halberg, N., & Pinto Correia, T. (2023). Successful stakeholder participation to address soil needs. EJP SOIL policy brief.

Deliverables and reports

Wall, D., Phillips, A., Marandola, D., O’Sullivan, L., Gascuel, C., Jacob, M., Orman, T., Higgins,S., Lansac, R., Sanches, B., Verhagen, J., Gerasina, R., & Chenu, C. (2021). Deliverable 8.1: Methodology for policy stakeholder survey/interviews. EJP SOIL Work Package 8 Deliverable.

Wall, D., Jacobs, A., Don, A., Sanches, B., Gascuel, C., O’Sullivan, L., Carlenius Berggreen, L.,Verhagen, J., Bieroza, M., Jacob, M., Heller, O., Kuikman, P., Kasparinskis, R., Lansac, R., & Higgins, S. (2021). Mapping policy stakeholders up to EU level across EJP SOIL Partner Countries. EJP SOIL Work Package 8 Deliverable.

 

Incentives and policy evaluation

The EJP SOIL concentrated on existing European policies (e.g., Farm2Fork strategy), on policies under development (Carbon Removals and Carbon Farming Regulation, Soil Monitoring and Resilience Directive) as well as on existing incentives, such as carbon faming schemes). Economic incentives for C sequestration, i.e. carbon farming schemes were inventoried and analysed, which allows to drive recommendations (e.g. Cruiscoli et al. 2024). Scenario modelling helps assessing the effect of policies or monitoring the policy goals set (e.g. Farm to Fork goals for 2030 and 2050).

Peer reviewed articles

Bellassen V.; Angers D.; Kowalczewski T.; Olesen A. 2022. Soil carbon is the blind spot of European national GHG inventories. Nature Climate Change, 12: 324-331.

Criscuoli, I., Martelli, A., Falconi, I., Galioto, F., Lasorella, M. V., Maurino, S., Phillips, A., Bonati,G., Guccione, G. D. 2024. Lessons learned from existing carbon removal methodologies foragricultural soils to drive European Union policies. European Journal of Soil Science, 75 (5), e13577.

Di Gregorio, L., Nolfi, L., Latini, A., Nikoloudakis, N., Bunnefeld, N., Notarfonso, M., Bernini, R.,Manikas, I., Bevivino, A. 2024. Getting (ECO)Ready: Does EU Legislation Integrate Up-to-Date Scientific Data for Food Security and Biodiversity Preservation Under Climate Change?Sustainability 2024, 16(23), 10749.

Policy briefs and notes

Chenu, C. (2022). Contribution of the EJP SOIL programme to the Soil Health call for evidence 2022-03-15

Criscuoli, I., Galioto, F., Martelli, A., Falconi, I., Dara Guccione, G., & Hvarregaard Thorsøe, M.(2024). Towards a regulation on carbon removals in the EU: lessons learned from existing experiences. EJP SOIL policy brief. Zenodo. 

 

Deliverables and Reports

Castanheira, N., Paz, A., & Gonçalves, M. C. (2022). Knowledge and sustainable management of agricultural soils in Portugal: Barriers and opportunities. Congresso Ibérico das Ciências do Solo 2022.

Farina, R., Di Bene, C., Marchetti, A., Piccini, C., & Vanino, S. (2021). Report on barriers andopportunities (knowledge and policy) at regional, national and EU levels for further harmonization and collaboration concerning research, data training, and education. EJP SOIL Work Package 2 Deliverable.

Keesstra, S. D., Jacob, M., Maenhout, P., Verzandvoort, S. J. E., Ruysschaert, G., Huber, S., Schwarzl, B., Huygebaert, B., Jacob , M., Hvarregaard Thorsøe, M., Vervuurt, W., & de Haan, J. J. (2021). Towards climate-smart sustainable management of agricultural soils: Deliverable 2.5 Report on identified regional, national and European aspirations on soil services and soil functions. EJP SOIL Work Package 2 Deliverable. Wageningen University & Research.

 

Datasets

Astover, A., Escuer-Gatius, J., & Don, A. (2021). Questionnaire and survey results to the report “Inventory of the use of models for accounting and policy support (soil quality and soil carbon)” [Data set].

Webinars & Educational Materials

Bellassen, V., Angers, D., Kowalczewski, T., & Olesen, A. (2022). Soil Carbon – the blind spot of European national GHG Inventories. EJP SOIL snack card.

Schmaltz, E. M., Johannsen, L. L., Hvarregaard Thorsøe, M., Tahtikarhu, M., Rasanen, T. A., Darboux, F., & Strauss, P. (2024). Policy challenges for soil erosion control. EJP SOIL snack card. 

Thorsøe, M.H (2024). Carbon farming schemes – Analysis and online Map. EJP SOIL snack cards.

Capacity building and education

Sustainable and climate smart management of soils requires human and institutional capacity, expertise and competencies in soil science and agronomy. Soil science related expertise will be more and more in high demand to serve academic, policy and practices of the European Green Deal, the EU Soil Strategy for 2030 and the proposed EU Directive on Soil Monitoring and Resilience. The established baseline of soil science in higher education (Barron and Villa, 2022) was complemented with an analysis of skills needed in the future for fostering sustainable soil management, and of related professional profiles (Veenstra et al. 2024, Walter et al. 2024).

Peer reviewed articles

Veenstra, J., Coquet, Y.,Melot, R., & Walter, C. 2024. A European stakeholder survey on soil science skills for sustainable agriculture. European Journal of SoilScience,75 (2): e13449.

Walter, C; Veenstra, J; Melot, R; Coquet, Y. 2024. Identification of soil-related professional profiles for the future from a survey of European stakeholders. European Journal of Soil Science, 75:e13469.

Policy briefs and notes

Barron, J., & Villa, A. (2022). Soil Science in higher education in Europe current state and recommendations. EJP SOIL policy brief. 

Webinars & Educational Materials

Villa Solis, A., Fahlbeck, E., & Barron, J. (2021). Soil science in higher education across Europe. EJP SOIL snack card.